…; ? sale, Fournelle ou Cournelle, Paris (Joullain), 14 October 1776, no. 71 (‘Paysan gardant un troupeau, à la pierre noire & lave’), with no. 72, 12 frs, to ‘? Hamon’; …; collection Gilbert Paignon Dijonval (1708-92), Paris;{According to the catalogue for the sale, Prof. Dr Friedrich Heimsoeth, Frankfurt-am-Main (F.A.C. Prestel), 5 May 1879 sqq., no. 12.} his grandson, Charles-Gilbert, Vicomte Morel de Vindé (1759-1842), Paris, by 1810;{According to P.M. Bérnard, Cabinet de M. Paignon Dijonval: état étaillé et raisonné des dessins et estampes dont il est composé; le tout gouverné par peintres classés par écoles, et rangés à leurs dates; suivi de deux tables alphabétiques, l'une des peintres, l'autre des graveurs, Paris 1810, p. 102, under no. 2273.} from whom, with 5999 other drawings and 60,000 prints, 125,000 frs, to the dealer S. Woodburn, London, 1816;{According to L. 2520.} …; collection Thomas Dimsdale (1758-1823), London (L. 2426); …; sale, Prof. Dr Friedrich Heimsoeth (1814-77, Bonn), Frankfurt-am-Main (F.A.C. Prestel), 5 May 1879 sqq., no. 12, DM 33;{Copy RKD.} …; sale, Georg Carl Valentin Schöffer (1841-1915, Amsterdam and Scheveningen), Amsterdam (F. Muller), 30 May 1893 sqq., no. 22, fl. 32, to William Pitcairn Knowles (1820-94), Rotterdam and Wiesbaden (L. 2643);{Copy RKD.} his sale, Amsterdam (F. Muller), 25 June 1895 sqq., no. 50, fl. 115, to the dealer C.F. Roos for the Vereniging Rembrandt;{Copy RKD; note RMA.} from whom, with 74 other drawings, fl. 3,253.50, to the museum (L. 2228), 1897